433 Comments

Every single day you remind us to be better people and create a better America. Thanks so much for your intelligent and informed writing.

Expand full comment

What she said - same here.

Expand full comment

'Tis the season to remind that the Trump family charity stole from kids with cancer and disabled veterans. Santa needs help carrying enough coal....according to Santa, the amount depends on how bad those Trumps have been. Needs a train.

https://ag.ny.gov/press-release/2019/donald-j-trump-pays-court-ordered-2-million-illegally-using-trump-foundation

https://www.courier-journal.com/story/life/holiday/2017/12/20/kentucky-coal-christmas-santa-children/882810001/

And don't forget to have a great Kwansa, Saturn's Day, Babaalu's saint's day and most especially the feast of the circumcision when the minion held a reception at the brith. Kiss 2023 bye bye. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7aN4QpL1_GE

Expand full comment

You are funny though I know you didn’t intend it to be. We are all angry with Trump and his supporters.

Did you see that Ivanka and Jared went to give the people support in Gaza?

~ Copycats of Diana ~ To deflect the fact that Jared was paid off (billions) by the Crown Prince for his father-in-law (Trump) not investigating him for the death and dismemberment of journalist, JAMAL KHASHOGGI.

WHY isn’t the House investigating Jared?? Write your representatives, contact the media and DEMAND they do so!

Merry Christmas and/or Happy Hanukkah! 🎄🕎

Expand full comment

Say his name

JAMAL KHASHOGGI

Expand full comment

We should SCREAM his name!

Expand full comment

YES

Expand full comment

"Daddy's Liddle Slutchild" and her man-wife went there for photo ops and NOTHING more! They care about getting the bigliest share daddy's "vast wealth" when the berders, or "Big Bubba" in prison, finish him off. That is IT.

Expand full comment

It’s so transparent; it’s actually an insult to Diana’s memory.

Expand full comment

Yes, so please do not associate it with that.

Expand full comment

Trying not to but I am sure it was contrived.

Jared’s Jewish & so is Ivanka now…

Expand full comment

Perfect

Expand full comment

Ditto to your Ever relevant comment !

Expand full comment

Also the same. We can do better.

Expand full comment

Actually, it’s not just Americans who worry about the USA.

And from Germany, it sure looks like a playbook we‘ve seen before.

Expand full comment

German here. Can confirm.

Expand full comment

A second German here, and it heartens me that America's two biggest allies were our WWII enemies: Germany and Japan! Who's helping us prevent vlad from consuming ALL of The USSR's former lands: GERMANY AND JAPAN.

Fröhliche Weihnachten!

Expand full comment

Americans can never again attribute Germany’s fascist period to some defect in its national character. Our Trump Moment amply illustrates that the United States is susceptible to the same insanity.

Expand full comment

Wars seldom end with peace treaties. They are often followed by more wars and even genocide. What the USA did with Germany and Japan after WW II was highly unusual and truly amazing. Both countries became free and prosperous with US help. We ought to be able to accomplish at home what we accomplished abroad.

Expand full comment
Dec 21, 2023·edited Dec 22, 2023

Mythical narratives are driving the problem here. People who have >absolutely no idea< what came down in those dark days have bought into heroic nonsense about it to avoid the guilt they bear for and justify the excesses they were and continue to be party to here. They like that "Übermensch" feeling they get from believing they're some kind of half-assed master race. Bad news. Bigotry is egalitarian, as well.

Expand full comment

Merry Christmas and happy holidays to all who have been so supportive of the thoughts and traditions that drive our Democracy. As long as the spark that you represent brings warmth to the hearts of our people, we stand a chance. God Bless and thanks Robert for being a giant among men.

Expand full comment

So true, Donald. Robert Reich has the biggest and most generous heart of any public figure I can think of today. He’s the true definition of a Mensch.

Expand full comment

You too, Donald.

Expand full comment

Definitely a giant among men. Did you know Robert Reich was a Rhodes Scholar as well? I just recently learned that from Wikipedia when I was quoting him trying to “educate” a staunch Republican on Nextdoor.com (in a National political group).

Expand full comment

Happy Holidays to you and your loved ones. Thank you for sharing your thoughts and intellect with me and all who will listen. In all of my 88 years I finally have someone that I trust with information that is accurate Much love to you You are truly my hero. Please keep up the good work

Expand full comment

Donna--Thanks for the kind thoughts, Ditto back to you. Have a great set of holidays. 2024 holds a few unknowns. Keep good thoughts and my best wishes to you and yours.

Expand full comment

Yes, and this idea of a superior man is seen in all sorts of things: he has to eat meat, have guns and say they are ready to use them at the drop of a hat, wrap themselves in the flag, be ready to offend before being offended, try to "own the libs", and of course, they cannot be gay. when they say jokes, those jokes have to be offensive to anything that is not white and male and 'Christian', at least what their version of Christianity is, really a heresy. This hyper [and fake] masculinity is seriously toxic.

Now that the Pope himself will allow same sex marriages, what will be their rationale for hating LGBTQs?

Expand full comment

These KKK types never had any use for Catholics or the Pope or anyone else who was not born white male and Protestant!

Expand full comment

True enough.

Expand full comment

Embracing a heretical fundamentalist Protestant sect - like they've already been doing.

Expand full comment

Maybe they will try to impeach the Pope!

Expand full comment

Can’t wait for one of the Constitution loving Magats to ask can we do that?

Expand full comment

Same thing in France: My sister is wondering what the hell is happening in this country. My niece, a Catholic nun sees the hatred of some Americans against LGBTQ and is also wondering: what the hell is happening here. How can Republicans think they are patriots when they hate some Americans? It is hard to love a country when you hate its people.

Expand full comment

And rightly so. We must strive to do much better. The good we have done in Gaza is hugely insufficient. And we MUST continue to support Ukraine for the sake of her people and of her many neighbors.

Expand full comment

indeed. I see both Ukraine and Israel as the bulwarks that protect our way of life. We must support them more. The problem is: Germany doesn't have enough military equipment anymore. For a long time, people hoped for disarmament and now that we have done it, because "we are surrounded by friends", which is a famous quote by a former German defense minister in the 90s, it's wrong. Unfortunately, we need weapons and ammunition to defend our liberal western democracies.

Expand full comment

I used to be supportive of Isreal but they are killing SOOOO many innocent people, come on, get better of what you doing.

Expand full comment

Hamas killed innocent people and knew what the response would be like. For Israel it is a matter of self defense to make sure that Hamas won't be able to fire rockets into Israel or try an invasion again.

Yes, too many people get killed. But as soon as Hamas stops the war on Israel, the killing will be over.

Expand full comment

I’m supporting Israel

not that Bungler BB Netanyahu he is trying to bomb his way in to office.

Killing innocent civilians is creating future terrorist, so it appears at his goal is forever War to stay in power. Kind of Like Putin keep the focus off them and start stupid wars.

Netanyahu Killed his own hostages because he on an revenge kick not a save anybody his troops are shooting first and asking questions last they were just three more “ Palestinians they gonna have to kill sooner or later anyway”

No Trigger control just shoot everyone and see what happens.

2,000 pound bombs are in discriminate weapons by design.

Expand full comment

It's a literal genocide of the Palestinian people and their culture. 20,000 dead. Mosques, medical schools, hospitals, grammar schools all destroyed. Who knows how many orphans created? How many children dead or maimed? Now they are starving and cold. Sickness and more death are coming.The hostages don't matter. In fact three were killed by the IDF. Anyone supporting this is delusional and heartless. Their obvious goal is the erasure of what's left of Palestine so they can take their land and their natural gas. Many acknowledge that this is the goal. They're destroying as many people and as much infrastructure as they can get away with every day. Open your eyes. They are the chosen people in their own minds only. Bless those rabbis and other Jewish folks who are speaking out against this horror and against Zionism.

Expand full comment

it's not a genocide. It's terrible that so many people are dying, but please look up the definition of genocide. Genocide is what Hamas wants to achieve.

Expand full comment

The ongoing carpet bombing of Palestine is an inhumane tragedy but also a political mistake by Netanyahu. It is important to bear in mind that not everyone living in Israel and not every individual within the Judaic faith supports or is carrying out this self destructive genocide, lest we lose our shared humanity. The actual culprits are not a people but individuals on all ‘sides’ with names and faces who must be held to account for crimes against humanity.

Expand full comment

Canada is in much the same boat. Hopefully while we are getting out of it, we can manage to do some of the manufacturing at home.

Expand full comment

We could have plenty of money to help both areas if we stopped paying the Congress people. They could be paid for "things" would improve out country. Kick out the Maga people they are corrupt!

Expand full comment

Sir, you are one of the “helpers” that Fred Rogers referred to. Your optimism is contagious. Deepest gratitude to you for your level headed, intelligent direction, compassion, and hopeful attitude. Warmest wishes to you and your loved ones this holiday season.

Expand full comment

If it were up to me, I'd vote for Dr. Reich to become a "National Treasure" and not post mortem, and begin the search for artists to make at the very least a statue or a name a national building, park (not a wilderness, for has surely led us out of the wilderness). I hereby cast the 1st vote...

Expand full comment

Adding my vote. In my impatience, I don't want to wait for the statue. Is there a Robert Reich bobblehead? I'll put it next to my Adrian Monk bobblehead. ❤️ to all, especially Dr Reich.

Expand full comment

Maintaining or common good begins and ends with us. So grateful for you. Happy holidays to you and your family!

Expand full comment

Robert Reich you are a gift to all the decent Americans who value inclusivity and diversity. It is my holiday wish that some of the numb far right find it in their hearts to embrace the decency of an America for anyone who seeks it's haven. Blessings from Jamaica.

Expand full comment
Dec 21, 2023·edited Dec 21, 2023

In the beginning you said our dominant religion doesn't define America. At the end you said it's our common morality that binds us. Many people don't separate religion and morality, especially those who didn't go to college. They get their morality from their religion. I think empathy, learning to walk a mile in "their" shoes (anyone's) is important. Not sympathy, but empathy. And education is supremely important! It has always been the road out of poverty.

Expand full comment

Many of the religious right believe non-believers have no moral compass. As an atheist, I think my moral compass is stronger than many of those who claim to be Christian.

Expand full comment

Without getting into questions of belief or non-belief, it's also fair to say (and philosophers do say it) that when you're talking about morality you should, in their words, “throw God out of the window”. What they mean is that your morality should be independent of your beliefs. If you're doing something for a reward (in this case presumably getting a pass through the pearly gates) then maybe that's why you've done it. If you've done it without thought for reward then that's where the morality kicks in, regardless of whether you believe or not.

It amuses me that some of those judgemental religious right wingers believe in the prosperity gospel. Presumably their moral compass can be summed up entirely by the filthy lucre they're hoping to gain! So yes, your moral compass is infinitely stronger than theirs. You believe in doing right purely because it's right.

Expand full comment
founding

I agreer Karen! <3

Expand full comment

Don’t remember reading about any atheists or agnostics in the history of the Inquisition or the Crusades .Hmmmm who was responsible for those lovely atrocities?

Expand full comment

Count me in that crew as well. Try suggesting to a "Christian" that they actually say that the only reason he (or she) says they are moral is their fear of the afterlife. I think many would find the heaven described in the bible rather hellish.

Expand full comment

My mother lived through the battle of Britain and used to say that if anything were to start WW3, it would probably be religious differences. The Constitution has it right: Freedom of religion!!~ Personally I think we need a non-violent laissez-faire attitude towards people who also good and non-violent. Live and let live, if everyone can agree to it. Unfortunately that may be just a pipe dream.

Expand full comment

I lived thru the Battle of Britain, too!

Who cares?!

Expand full comment

Happy Holidays to Professor Reich and Heather and thanks for the newsletter!

Expand full comment

Today is the winter solstice, the shortest day of the year, the longest night. After tonight, the days get longer until the June 20 solstice. We can think of today is the end of a solar cycle. We can imagine what we want for the coming solar year. We can set our goals, and mark our calendars with what to do toward those goals, every day. May it go well for all.

Expand full comment

A liittle nit picky here, my apologies, but the days don't start getting longer until Dec 25th, when (in the eyes of our ancestors) the sun stops its descent into the grave (the underworld), where it lay three days after the solstice, and arises, thus hallelujah, the promise of ever lasting life on Earth

Happy Dec 25th Dr Reich, an insprational message indeed,

Expand full comment

Today is also the day to memorialize unsheltered human beings who perished on the streets in the past year. Give a thought for those who can't enjoy a cup of hot chocolate from the comfort of their home and time to stay informed of things other than just surviving another night.

Expand full comment

well I'll be damned. So it is.

Expand full comment

Happy Holidays to all! Thanks for your intelligence, insight and for all you do to remind us to be better. VOTE in 2024!

Our lives depend on it.

Expand full comment

Proud to be part of this community of like-minded people ~ happy holidays!

Expand full comment

Once again I feel compelled to remark that much - perhaps all - of what you write could apply equally well to the UK. But I have a lot of friends in the USA, and wish them a happy time this season, however they celebrate it. We may all hope for improvements in the conduct of public life, on both sides of the Atlantic.

Expand full comment

We watched a "truish" movie on Netflix last evening, "The Bank of Dave" which takes place in northern U.K. Neoliberalism caused the same issues in the U.K. as in the U.S. I recommend this movie, especially for young people to help understand how the world works. Good wishes.

Expand full comment

Looking at the synopsis things have always been like that.Thrifts in the USA ( savings and loans ),Credit unions here,non existent now.Terminating and permanent building societies in the UK,almost non existent now.

A terminating building society explains it well.Say the candlestick makers decide to fund mortgages.They all put their wages into the candlestick makers building society .One person per year is drawn out of the hat to receive that money to build a house.Repeat annually ,they can't survive

A large bank can survive.Bank of America has $1.9 trillion on deposit.They can lend that money out for mortgages.The last time I looked the large banks had $12 (?) trillion on deposit.The US system is different to the rest of the world so can have 30 year fixed mortgages,Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac.

Still the same,the candlestick makers small bank that struggles.The huge bank where you can access the money.The large bank can operate on smaller profit margins than the small bank.

Expand full comment

Before emigrating my grandparents lived in the north of England.Great for me and great for them that they emigrated .Great for me because it meant I could have dual nationality.

I haven't watched that film but there are 3 Ken Loach films that are a must watch.

Cathy come home from the 1960s.Then I,Daniel Blake.2015?. Then sorry we missed you 2019..

Watching things happen was strange as industry left the area.The UK was a work stop in travels around the world.

Trying to educate people financially was just as pointless in the 1970s 1980s and 1990s as it is now.

Those films are worth watching.Apart from Michael Moore died the USA not have people of that ilk?

Expand full comment

Thank your Dr. Reich, and all the best to you and yours!

The Common Good, which shares a lot with The Golden Rule, is indeed a good thought to hold through the holiday season.

Living in community with all who share this Pale Blue Dot is worth aspiring to.

Expand full comment

I admire and respect you RR!! A magnificent life of service to us ! So grateful for your dedication and message of remembrance of the Common Good for our Nation... to remain united despite our differences!

You are a shining light!!!

Happy Holidays ☮️💟

Expand full comment

Wishing you and yours a wonderful end and beginning of the year! Thanks for keeping me sane!

Expand full comment

Robert, Happy Holidays to you. And thank you for our continuing education and a place to come together. We really do hold power in numbers and intellect. We can do this! And I believe we will.

Expand full comment