237 Comments

I agreed with everything right up to the last. But the best way to avoid false equivalencies is for the responsible press to stop making them. It was press coverage, mainstream as well as partisan, that weaponized Benghazi and emails against Hillary.

Expand full comment

Exactly right. I was so fed up with the media headlines hyperbolizing this issue that I wrote letters this morning to the Times and Post saying they were part of the problem. Said there was a difference between accurate reporting by professional journalism and clickbait, tabloid headlines for profit. Doesn't matter that the media includes caveats below in their articles to explain the false equivalence, because the emotional impact of their headlines is what sticks in memories. And it's divisive as hell.

Expand full comment

YES!!!!!

Expand full comment

You are spot on!

Expand full comment

Both are true at the same time; what you say and RR’s advice to Biden. The press, incl the NYT and WAPO, has been so transparently craven:the screaming headlines for those looking for any equivalence, and then covering their behinds with bullet points about differences for the chorus to read.

Expand full comment

Do you think that WaPo has been equally bad (equivalent to) as the NYT?

Expand full comment

Both papers in this case, in my opinion, have been equally bad regarding the Biden documents. WAPO had bold full page headlines on their front page. The NYT had theirs front page left side. Both covered themselves with clarifications of the differences. For those that are only interested in headlines that’s all that is needed.

Expand full comment

Whew! Thank you.

Expand full comment
Comment removed
Jan 16, 2023
Comment removed
Expand full comment

There is a process legally to classify documents. Highly classified documents are not de-classified on a whim---or as trump said, to simply think it and they are not classified. Not only that, documents are NOT the property of anyone; they are directed to go to the Department of Archives. One, is required to keep all documents, including those written memos that we all do at work. Add to that, DOJ requested that trump be held in contempt of court because he refused to release said documents; indeed, he said they were his. Sadly, a Federal Judge did not uphold said request.

There is the Rule of Law to release all documents; trump doesn't regard any laws except his own.

https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/18/3a.22#:~:text=(1)%20All%20information%20and%20material,information%20or%20material%20which%20the

Expand full comment

Chuck-That Trump had authority (a process he did not follow) and Biden did not did not is moot because that is not what this is about. Had Trump followed the process there would still be an issue of taking away (stealing) boxes of documents, some classified and top secret, to keep that belong to the American people and refusing, resisting the return. As well compromising US security by keeping them at his country club. Did Biden steal the documents he had or were they inadvertently held in his office/s, papers, found, and returned?

Expand full comment

You know I wondered the same thing when Comey came out right before the election 2016 with the e- mails of Hillary and Dons election cycle. I believed it was wrong.

Expand full comment
Comment removed
Jan 17, 2023
Comment removed
Expand full comment

They admit they kept the news because of exactly what happened:it blew up in the news as a gotcha. As far as "keeping in three different places" I did not know whether you refer to Trump or Biden. Biden's were in his papers. Trump in boxes taken. You are smelling Biden but have forgotten the stench of Trump.

Expand full comment
Comment removed
Jan 17, 2023
Comment removed
Expand full comment

15 BOXES. that belonged to the National Archives were retrieved. Retrieved!

“Of the documents retrieved by NARA from Mar-a-Lago, archivists and federal agents determined that 184 unique documents had classification markings, of which 25 were marked "top secret", 92 "secret" and 67 "confidential".[6][7] Some materials were governed by special access programs (SAP), a type of protocol reserved for extremely sensitive U.S. operations conducted abroad, intended to significantly limit access to the information.[8][9][10]” quote from Wikipedia.

Expand full comment

As was said .. it was under wraps and then THEY revealed after the election because of the gotcha seeking the GOP operatives do consistently. They were then FORTHCOMING. Chunk cut it out already.

Expand full comment

They kept it be

Expand full comment
Comment removed
Jan 17, 2023
Comment removed
Expand full comment

Chuck… all over the place? You are really into false equivalency? Trump carted out boxes!! Refused to return voluntarily. You sre just being obtuse and wanting the gotcha to not focus on the obvious difference. You cannot be reasoned with.

Expand full comment

Are you saying that Biden was in the wrong, but the orange sadist was in the right. Not understanding your post, and would appreciate clarification. Thanks.

Expand full comment
Comment removed
Jan 17, 2023
Comment removed
Expand full comment

But trump DIDN'T declassify! He just took everything with him, and when told to return it, said "It's MINE!" and refused to comply with the law. He SAID he did, but he was either lying or delusional, I'm never sure which. Where are you getting your information?

Expand full comment
Comment removed
Jan 17, 2023
Comment removed
Expand full comment

Thank you for your kind words. I'll be sure not to enter another discussion in the future.

Expand full comment
Comment deleted
Jan 13, 2023
Comment deleted
Expand full comment

Yes, thanks. I blame this phenomenon (irresponsible press prioritizing advertising and “views” over nuance and facts) as a primary cause of Trump’s election in the first place. “But her e-mails ….”

Expand full comment

As a professor himself, he could be very influential with them.

Expand full comment

Exactly. Ignore the distractions and get on with the agenda.

Expand full comment

President Biden has already achomplished so much in two years! [sic] I know he won't let a few obsolete, sad "f_cking morons" upset his plans . . . let's hope anyway.

Expand full comment

Yes: LET'S ALL HOPE!!!

Expand full comment

There IS no equivalence! Did President Biden possibly commit a crime? Maybe. Did Bunkerboy ABSOLUTELY commit MANY, MANY, MANY CRIMES, then refuse to own up to them? Absolutely!

Expand full comment

That's the one thing DeadbeatTrump does well, break laws and lie.

Expand full comment

76 and Republicans have been solid liars since the 50s with Traitor Joe McCarthy who my friend's late father helped bring down

Expand full comment

And now we have an equally reprehensible McCarthy leading the House.

Expand full comment

Ironic, isn't it.

Expand full comment

Ironic -- and TERRIFYING!

Expand full comment

YAY for your father!!

Expand full comment

Biden would not have committed a crime, it is an ethics issue.

Expand full comment

@Seeking. Or political sabotage...

Expand full comment

Benjamin, I assume you’re referring to GQP. YES, there is absolutely NOTHING they wouldn’t do. The main reason they needed to rid themselves of the Ethics Office. They commit atrocities over and over because there are no consequences.

Expand full comment

I was just referring to the fact that it would not be classified as an actual crime but a matter of ethics. I don’t believe Biden would do such a blatant ethics violation like the orange lunatic who-thinks-he’s-king would.

Expand full comment

Daniel H L, And still going at it! There is no equivalency whatsoever!

Expand full comment
Comment deleted
Jan 13, 2023
Comment deleted
Expand full comment

SandyC I fully disagree. You know that the Rs are already repeating it as if there is an equivalency between the two. They have the audacity to mention it while their fascist-loving coup inciting criminal still awaits any justice at all. It would have been downright stupid for Democrats to do so. The media is owned by ultra right, we’re not going to suddenly incur rational thought from them.

Expand full comment
Comment deleted
Jan 14, 2023
Comment deleted
Expand full comment

Because we are under the thumb of fascists. I do not believe for one moment Biden would intentionally hide documents. Remember, one of his sons died during this time. Whereas one of the worst criminals in US history is being protected by the republican party, therefore, they have no right whatsoever to open their damn mouths regarding any infraction by anyone else.

Expand full comment
Comment removed
Jan 13, 2023
Comment removed
Expand full comment

The advantage of having a special prosecutor for the Biden documents is that it will be possible to get to the bottom of the issue: Who put the documents into the containers in which they were found? Was it Biden or someone else? Could this be a set-up by Biden’s enemies? I ask this because political sabotage is an obvious motive — in this case, it’s an easy copy-cat crime that might have been accomplished by a Watergate-style “burglar” team. It might be easy to bribe an employee of U. Penn or the Biden household to enable the planting of the documents. As everyone knows, the Republicans have lots of money to spend on nefarious deeds. The special prosecutor will find out.

Expand full comment

Or some of the Secret Service agents loyal to Trump & now working for Biden.

Expand full comment

Biden has not a tenth of the corruption and lies of Deadbeat Trump. Wake up. Trump has been a cheat and liar big time since the 80s. Where are my steaks and Trump U degree Deadbeat Trump?

Expand full comment

Are you a lawyer? Biden’s “team” is showing dumbass rePUGliCONs how it’s done! Media owned by rich white rePUGliCONs say what THEY want us to hear!

Expand full comment

When the GOP makes a stink about the documents (it doesn't matter who found them and that it is a false equivalency) they are admitting TFG having documents is a crime. Good. If Biden isn't squeaky clean we're going to have to accept it and deal with it, as Garland is doing. This is how we show we're different from the GOP.

Expand full comment

Yes, I liked that Garland picked someone appointed by Trump but generally believed to be ethical.

Expand full comment

Somehow, media outlets are hesitant to wonder whether the small number of documents found among Biden's papers were planted there? Indeed, the timing of them being discovered seems like such a lucky "accident" for the Republicans that it's actually rather hard to swallow that those papers were hiding there for the many years since Biden was VP without having been found sooner. Just wondering...

Expand full comment

I agree, Benjamin R !

Expand full comment

@Laurie. ;-D

Expand full comment
Comment deleted
Jan 13, 2023Edited
Comment deleted
Expand full comment

Hi, Janet!

DZK (I think that's what he goes by) convinced me a few days ago that this is a possibility.

It is wise to be skeptical of conspiracy theories, but Republicans have proven that sometimes they can be valid. If you think of the worst thing they could do, that often is what they would do.

Expand full comment
Comment deleted
Jan 14, 2023
Comment deleted
Expand full comment

It may have been in an earlier Reich column. Not sure I can find it. However, I just got a comment that disappeared from the comment section, & so did my response.

Expand full comment
Comment deleted
Jan 15, 2023Edited
Comment deleted
Expand full comment

Alright. Next time you see DZK, you can ask about it. I'm sure he'd love to talk about it.

Expand full comment
Comment deleted
Jan 14, 2023
Comment deleted
Expand full comment

You have a great weekend, too, Janet!

Expand full comment
Comment deleted
Jan 15, 2023
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
Comment removed
Jan 13, 2023
Comment removed
Expand full comment

@Jack Velten. Biden's own personnel found the documents. It might have been ethically dubious for the Biden Administration not to immediately announce something, but it might have also been a responsible act not to announce disruptive news items: 1) in the middle of an election when normal election processes might have been impacted, and 2) before all the facts were fully known. If you read the news you will know that a reporter first breached the news, not the Administration.

Expand full comment

I agree with you, Stan.

Besides, Biden has been in po!itics too long to know better than to do this.

Expand full comment

Republican House of Representatives Day 4: Promises made and what's been done

Inflation-Nothing, Crime, nothing, Immigration Noting, education Nothing, Healthcare nothing, Fentanyl death nothing.

Expand full comment

Get used to it; those Republican Reps aren't in Congress to represent YOU, silly...they are in there to generate fake outrage and throw meaty but insubstantial morsels to their drooling cult base.

Expand full comment

All sizzle, no steak.

Expand full comment

Actually, they did accomplish something: destroy the House Ethics Committee.

Expand full comment

And that action was solely for the benefit of those members who have something to hide and some potential criminal exposure by asking for a pardon and other supportive acts of the insurrectionists. No other person or government body benefits from such a self-interested move.

Expand full comment
Comment removed
Jan 13, 2023
Comment removed
Expand full comment

Jack Velten ; Go troll someplace else!

Expand full comment
Comment removed
Jan 17, 2023
Comment removed
Expand full comment

Birds of a feather...

Expand full comment

In less than two years Biden created more jobs than any other president before him.

Biden provided $1.9T in relief, TFG $1.9T tax cuts for uber wealthy & corporations.

Biden-$1.2T infrastructure package! TFG-No wall paid for by Mexico, Did NOT bring jobs back from China, as promised, Committed a laundry list of high crimes, incited a deadly coup, did NOT lower health costs.

Republican accomplishments : Stopped AG laws that prevented corporate farms, brought us McCarthyism, Iran Iraq war/occupation, JFK assassination, Iran Contra scandal.

Lots of accomplishments toward ruining the country & people.

Expand full comment

Seeking Reason ; The GOP also brought us a corrupt, stacked supreme court; Citizens United, Rupert Murdoch media, taxes on Social Security, weak FCC, FEC, EPA and now IRS. They do not even hide the fact that they want to keep people from voting or even having Democracy itself.

Expand full comment

Tell it sister! We need to compile the list and hand out all 17 pages for people to reference! 😄👍🏼

In all seriousness, a velvet revolution would be something…but we will probably be pushed further into ultimately seeing a violent one. Notice how Garland came out, stronger than ever to put on a show of investigating Biden. How about he show some urgency for arguably one of the worst criminals in US history. Or maybe we’ll wait another 2 years! 😡

Expand full comment

Seeking Reason; like Santos suggested: just have to "wait 2 years" to get rid of him.

Expand full comment

You absolutely get my point! I'll do the House you do the Senate. It isn't a competition, but more like tag team wrestling. Just because "we know that" doesn't mean we shouldn't keep pointing it out.

It wasn't always that the two parties won't speak to each other.

Expand full comment

How many parties would you like to see?

Expand full comment

Amen to that. He is a man of honor and direction. The GOP is lost and will continue to be that way until their direction is found and the fringe players ( the liars, crazies and self absorbed) are exposed for what they are and thrown out of our government.

Expand full comment

Oh, the GOP will definitely have a heyday with this bit of intel

Marjorie Taylor Groan has repeatedly said that Biden planted all of trump’s secret documents to trumpy

Expand full comment

I sometimes think that maybe a MAGA person planted the Classified documents in Biden's residences.

Expand full comment

Here , here!

Me thinks the MAGA protest way too much.

🤔😏

Expand full comment

Agreed, Kate!

Expand full comment
Comment removed
Jan 13, 2023
Comment removed
Expand full comment

Maybe your MAGA friends planted them in that third place? Since the investigation is just starting, it does not count to just assume he is guilty. You are not being fair minded, Jack Velten. If he is guilty. It will be found out. In the meantime, President Biden is a real President and has done some good for our voters unlike your guy and his MAGAt supporters.

Expand full comment

And maybe they weren’t planted at all and Biden did leave these documents in all the places they were discovered, his cognitive abilities are waning and he simply could have forgotten he was in possession of classified documents. He is a documented liar also.

Expand full comment

Maybe this and maybe that, Mike. That is why an investigation is warranted.

Expand full comment

Mike ; I'm sure you have never told a lie. But Biden has done more for the voters than anyone in recent memory, more than the minority MAGA 'leaders' for sure.

Expand full comment

...which probably means Republican operatives planted documents on Biden, since whatever Republicans accuse the Democrats of doing, the Republicans have already done, are now doing, or are contemplating doing.

Expand full comment

Jaime ; That' true!

Expand full comment

Hell yea,” Monkey See Monkey Do”.

Of course the monkey (s) here are our, One and Only- MAGA GOP (guns over people ) partisan puppets by -well

We all know who 🤨

Expand full comment

Creating chaos through a focus on procedure rather than addressing problems, and social policy is the tactic of the Right. ( Birther controversy about Obama comes to mind. And Trump learned that telling that lie didn’t have the usual repercussions that usually stick to an unmasked liar) Why don’t Americans know by now that these tactics are self defeating? That our lives are worse because of the time wasted avoiding real problems.

Expand full comment

Don't fall into their trap of distraction. Just run the Country and protect our Democracy.

Expand full comment

You seem to have missed a critical failure of the news media that did not look into the Trump White House staff removal of Secret documents in January 2021. The first public statement that I can find is from the national archives in January 2022 (1 year later!). The news media didn't really pick it up until August 2022 after months of Trump lies, denials, & claims that he owned those documents.

https://www.archives.gov/press/press-releases/2022/nr22-001#january-31-2022

Expand full comment

The result of years of underfunding education -- an unfortunately large percentage of the population will just run with whatever sound-bite they are fed.

Expand full comment
Comment removed
Jan 13, 2023
Comment removed
Expand full comment

@Jack Velten. Education is funded (under funded) at the local level. This is self-reinforcing since hyper-religious, under-educated, rural Republicans consistently under fund their own kids' education hoping to keep those kids enthralled to the superstitions of yesteryear and the false political narratives that the adults are lapping up. You are really a terrible troll. You don't seem to know even the basics. The Democrats and "blue states" fund education very well and then become attacked as "the coastal elites." If people in the "red states" would educate their kids appropriately, they could become the "heartland elites". But fearful, xenophobic, racist, anti-science, anti-vax parents don't really want their kids to be educated!

Expand full comment

Benjamin, 🎯

Expand full comment

Thanks for making the distinction about the document mess. The distinctions between the GOP & the Democrats are in high contrast in so many ways, yet we are all stil human beings. Merritt Garland is such an inappropriate AG. IMO, his placement at the DOJ is a glaring mistake. He seems frozen in inaction, fearful that holding Trump and his cronies to court proceedings will upset the GOP and start what? The overwhelming lawlessness is beyond started, its blooming and replicating with everyday he lets Trump & associates continue to walk freely. Citizens of the US pay dearly for all the mistakes being made today as well as those you referred to in a previous post where you described the corporate subsidies without regulation or accountability. The GOP wants a feudal state. We need braver people than Merritt Garland to resist those actions.

Expand full comment

I think you are wrong about Garland, he is doing his job and in my mind doing it well. Yes I a frustrated with the pace but I don't see it moving in the wrong direction or any kind of cover-up / white wash. Remember how long it took back in the 70's to bring cases against Nixon's inter circle. (I only wish Nixon hadn't been pardoned - that was a big mistake by Ford). As to Garland remember that he must be independent of Biden and the White House, not a repeat of Barr. My bottom line is that Trump must be charged and he should serve time for the rest of his "SAD" life.

Expand full comment

Absolutely. Why does Barr still have a law license? Every damn lawyer who tried to help trump and his corruption should have their licenses revoked.

Expand full comment

Justice delayed perpetuates the problem and lets it get magnified. The leader of the insurrection must be shutdown ASAP. Assassination is bad policy and a terrible precedent, so in this nasty, violent environment there must be JUDICIAL ACTION!

Expand full comment

Yes, I wonder if it'll take assassinations of politicians before we get action, or if even that's not enough.

Expand full comment

I disagree with your comment about Garland. I'm glad he appointed special counsel to check into this document situation with Biden. The GOP can't say Garland is playing favorites or whatever their newest conspiracy would be.

I'm also relieved he appointed Jack Smith to investigate trump and Jan 6. He's on the move, even though it doesn't look that way.

This corruption has so many players and facets to it. They'll be investigating for years.

Be grateful there are people who are doing their jobs. It's been a long time since we've watched real wheels of justice turn.

Expand full comment

Thank you for this message. If only all people who need to hear it would listen. I want to stay focused ,calm and informed but it is so awful watching this circus.

Expand full comment

“The task for Biden and the White House will be to keep an even keel ... the contrast between the House Republicans’ zany partisan escapades and Biden’s seriousness of public purpose will offer the most potent means of avoiding all false equivalences.”

Really? How’s that been working out for them?

The Democrats have been trying the “Let’s just ignore them and wait for people to see we’re the competent ones and vote for us” strategy for decades and all it’s accomplished is to embolden Republicans.

The Democrats need to stop waiting for sanity to prevail and start forcefully calling Republicans out on their shit.

Take just the recent confidential documents false equivalence. Dems should be united and overwhelming in their response, grabbing every reporter within reach and challenging them, forcefully, to their faces, on their making up facts and deliberately distorting what happened.

More “Oh, that’s bullshit, Chuck, and you know it. Now do your job right and stop being a shill for Republican lies.” And no more “Well, gosh, I’m not going to question your reporting because that would be rude. I’ll just passively wait for people to figure it out for themselves.”

Expand full comment

I guarantee you Trump's people planted those documents. Why else would it take 4 years to discover them? Biden never took documents out of the Skiff. It would not have been possible for them to get where they were found. His garage?!! Right. That's just where a head of state goes to examine documents. Not. It IS an easy place to gain access to by some lowlife Trump hired. It's obvious.

Expand full comment

Agree. In a few words. Project Veritas. O’Keefe excels at this.

Expand full comment