Robert Reich

Share this post

Today's Biden-McCarthy meeting: A "framing" victory for McCarthy and the GOP

robertreich.substack.com

Today's Biden-McCarthy meeting: A "framing" victory for McCarthy and the GOP

It was framed as the start of negotiations, but the debt ceiling should be non-negotiable.

Robert Reich
Feb 2
802
379
Share this post

Today's Biden-McCarthy meeting: A "framing" victory for McCarthy and the GOP

robertreich.substack.com
President Biden sits down with Speaker McCarthy for a meeting.

This afternoon, President Biden met with House Speaker Kevin McCarthy on the debt ceiling.

Unfortunately, the meeting reinforced McCarthy’s and the Republicans’ message that raising the debt ceiling is a negotiable issue that should be dealt with by reducing spending.

The Washington Post described today’s meeting as the “kick off [to] talks aimed at averting a potentially catastrophic default on the national debt” and “the earliest stage of a messy political back-and-forth between the White House and Republicans over the federal debt ceiling.”

Sure sounds like the start of negotiations.

Politico reported that “Biden officials in the run-up to the meeting privately discussed the potential for a compromise that heads off a debt ceiling crisis while separately granting McCarthy small concessions that would allow him to save face with his party.”

Compromise? Concessions? We’re already at the negotiating table, folks.

I’ve been through several debt-ceiling crises. How they’re framed determines how the public understands what’s at stake. This framing puts the onus on Biden and the White House to negotiate.

Worse yet, the media isn’t providing context. The Washington Post reports that McCarthy “views the growing federal debt as the ‘greatest threat to America,’” and Republicans “are determined to use talks around raising the borrowing cap to rein in the federal debt.” But where’s the reporting of the enormous $7.8 trillion debt racked up by Trump and his Republican Congress? Or the willingness of Republicans to raise the debt ceiling three times under Trump? Or the fact that Republican-sponsored tax cuts on big corporations and the rich substantially worsened the debt?

The White House and the Democrats must do a better job framing the debt-ceiling issue. The media must do a better job reporting on it.

379
Share this post

Today's Biden-McCarthy meeting: A "framing" victory for McCarthy and the GOP

robertreich.substack.com
379 Comments
Janet R (CO)
Feb 2·edited Feb 2Liked by Robert Reich

The media helped create the destructive menace we know as Donald Trump. And they should’ve known better and realized the harm done in giving him a voice. That’s why I have no expectation that even once-respected news organizations like the New York Times and the Washington Post are going to live up to their reputations and report accurately about the difference between the debt ceiling and future spending. It’s going to be up to President Biden to get on his soapbox and talk about this to the American people, and soon. By allowing these rogue politicians to amplify their voices without fighting back is not going to bode well for 2024. 

Expand full comment
Reply
84 replies
Joseph Kasper
Feb 2Liked by Robert Reich

The debt ceiling should be non-negotiable. The debt ceiling is non-negotiable. According to my understanding of the US Constitution, 14th Amendment, Section 4, The validity of the public debt of the United States, authorized by law, including debts incurred . . . shall not be questioned."

Copied from: https://secondnexus.com/deadbeat-limit-understanding-debt-ceiling

and https://leisureguy.wordpress.com/2023/01/17/deadbeat-limit/

The Deadbeat Limit—Understanding The Debt Ceiling

Why do we keep ignoring the 14th Amendment?

Thank you for your consideration.

Expand full comment
Reply
44 replies
377 more comments…
TopNewCommunity

No posts

Ready for more?

© 2023 Robert Reich
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start WritingGet the app
Substack is the home for great writing