Sunday thought
Fighting the regime’s cruelty
Friends,
It’s been another grueling week.
Several of you have asked me how to live in a nation whose leader has embraced cruelty as public policy. How do we inhabit Trump’s America without becoming complicit in this cruelty?
Molly watched Trump sign the executive order initiating criminal investigations of Miles Taylor (who wrote an anonymous 2018 New York Times op-ed describing internal resistance to Trump in his first term) and Christopher Krebs (who played a major role in undercutting Trump’s false claims about 2020 election fraud).
Molly asks: Is this America?
No, Molly, it is not — at least not the America we have known and loved.
Others of you are thunderstruck by Trump’s cruelty toward refugees who fled violence and have been living in the United States legally but are now being forced to return to their home countries and face more violence.
And the Trump regime’s cruelty toward people here on temporary visas who are deported arbitrarily, without a hearing — some sent to a gruesome prison in El Salvador even after the regime has admitted error in sending them.
And children in poor countries who are in desperate need of vaccines but are now doing without them because Trump has ended USAID.
The cruelty toward vulnerable people in Gaza, in Ukraine, and in Yemen who are being bombed, wounded, or killed because the Trump regime is doing nothing to stop these bloodbaths or is contributing to them.
Cruelty toward tens of thousands of public servants who are suddenly and without warning fired — some just months away from retirement and a pension.
Revoking security protection for Biden’s son and daughter. And for General Mark Milley and Dr. Anthony Fauci.
Revoking security protection for other former members of his first administration despite warnings of ongoing threats from Iran because of actions they took on Trump’s behalf.
Firing more than a dozen prosecutors who worked for the special counsel Jack Smith on criminal investigations of Trump.
Revoking security clearances of 51 people who merely signed a letter suggesting that the contents of Hunter Biden’s laptop could be Russian disinformation.
Targeting law firms that employ or have employed lawyers who worked on investigations into Trump or on causes Trump objects to.
Targeting universities that have allowed international students freedom of speech.
And on it goes, day after day — the Trump regime’s abject cruelty, viciousness, heartlessness, brutality.
How does a moral person live with this? How do we not become complicit?
The answer, I think, is to do whatever we can to protect those who are vulnerable to this cruelty.
We speak out against Trump’s use of criminal investigations to punish public servants who helped expose his venality.
We make our communities into sanctuaries that limit local law enforcement’s cooperation with federal immigration authorities.
We urge our universities to protect free speech and expression of everyone, at whatever the cost.
To the extent we can, we fund groups that are helping poor families around the world get the medical assistance they need.
We call our senators and members of Congress to tell them to retrieve their constitutional authority over government spending.
We tell them to stop the brutality in Gaza, Ukraine, Yemen, and everywhere else America is either encouraging it or failing to discourage it.
We tell them to stop Trump’s criminal investigations of opponents.
We protest. We organize. We mobilize. We do what we can to put good people into office and keep them there, and we help regain control of Congress in next year’s midterm elections.
In other words, we become organized activists against Trump’s organized cruelty.
We try to make this country an America we can love again.
Years from now, when our children and grandchildren ask what we did during Trump’s reign of terror, we can tell them that we worked tirelessly to curb his cruelty — and we did it with our compassion.
The cruelty and malice, the violence, the dictatorial aspirations, the illegalities, the looting of our natural spaces, the looting of our social safety net, this is what America is becoming, while we struggle against the fascists, and that is what they are.
I will oppose them with every breath I have, because it is not too late yet and I refuse to let my children live in a mobster police state. America belongs to all of us!
Interesting you should write this Professor Reich. I wonder whether an ‘own-nation-centric’ worldview will help America get through this, especially focusing on the prevailing cultural narrative of American exceptionalism. I’ve just written this for an upcoming post:
"Looking globally is essential if we want to truly understand what’s happening in the US- and to anticipate what may come. A nation-centric, linear view treats American democracy as a self-contained story, unfolding according to its own internal choices and traditions. It focuses on domestic elections, Supreme Court rulings, and congressional battles, as if these alone determine the country’s trajectory. But democracy doesn’t erode in a vacuum. The forces destabilising it—disinformation, economic inequality, polarisation, institutional distrust—aren’t uniquely American. They’re global phenomena, driven by transnational networks of influence, shared strategies, and a rapidly evolving information landscape."
What's happening in the US didn't arise in a vacuum, and the answers won't be found in that vacuum. It's also likely that they'll not be the answers that have worked in the past. We need to look laterally, at what's happened/ is currently happening in other nation states where democracy is being dismantled to see what's to come, and learn new strategies to address it and protect ourselves and each another.